Showing posts with label Universal Health Care. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Universal Health Care. Show all posts

Friday, December 28

San Francisco "Pay or Play" DOA - ERISA Chews Up Another Pay or Play Law

Those of you who have been with us since the beginning (or have done some serious digging) know that one of our first posts at CE was on the unfortunate demise of the Suffolk County Fair Share Act, back in July. We said then that the Retail Industry Leaders of America was on a rampage trying to stop state "pay or play" healthcare laws by convincing federal judges they were per se preempted by ERISA - before Suffolk was a Maryland pay or play law that RILA put the brakes on.

How apropos, then, as we reflect on the year, that another business association has given us opportunity to revisit our earliest days. The Golden Gate Restaurant Association just got summary judgment in a lawsuit against the city of San Francisco in which it argued (what else) that the city's pay or play law, which was to go into effect next week, was preempted by ERISA.

From the Sacramento Business Journal:

Under the San Francisco plan, employers with 20 to 99 employees would have to spend $1.17 an hour per employee on health benefits or pay that amount to the city. Businesses with 100 employees or more would have to spend $1.76 an hour for each employee.

Judge Wright ruled that the mandate interferes with ERISA provisions that specifies employer autonomy over whether and how to provide employee coverage. The decision stems from a lawsuit filed by the Golden State Restaurant Association, which argued the mandatory contributions place a costly burden on business owners.


Man, when ERISA makes the MSM, you know something's going on. Though city attorney Michael Herrera is taking the appeal to the 9th Circuit, it's clear that the state is fighting this battle, since the SF plan is pretty much a petri dish for the statewide plan sitting the Cali Legislature.

As far as Herrera's chances go, his argument is not totally off base. From the city's press release:

“Although state and local laws that dictate employer choices about ERISA plans are preempted, legal requirements that employers may readily satisfy without altering or adopting ERISA plans are not because they do not interfere with uniform benefit plan administration,” Herrera argued. “San Francisco’s Ordinance clearly falls in this latter category, because it allows employers to comply with the health care spending requirement without adopting an ERISA plan or altering an existing ERISA plan. If an employer wishes to avoid the burdens of setting up a plan, or wishes to maintain plan uniformity across jurisdictions, it can simply make payments to the City, and those payments will make their employees eligible for substantial health benefits—benefits that would cost a great deal more in the private market.”


Going against Herrera, of course, is the fact that this argument has completely failed twice before. In his favor is 1.) logic (to a certain extent) and 2.) the fact that the 9th Circuit is crazy, and they seem to like poking the Supreme Court in the face with cases like this.

In the meantime, though, that ERISA keeps getting fatter and fatter on preempted laws. At the risk of biased commentary, may I suggest she at least start chewing up and spitting out, rather than swallowing them whole?

More After the Jump...

Thursday, July 19

Wal Mart 2, States 0: Suffolk County, NY Fair Share Act Shot Down.

How will all the destitute residents of East Hampton afford their hospital stays?!

Ok, that's a cheap shot, we know. There's plenty of places in Suffolk besides the Hamptons. Still, seems an odd place for championing healthcare reform to us, but what do we know?

Anyway, remember the Maryland Fair Share Act? Sure you do. It was the "pay or play" healthcare law that would've required Wal Mart and other enormous retailers (so, just Wal Mart) to pay a specified amount of their employee's health benefits or pay into a State-run subsidy program. Remember how it was crushed, like a bug on the ERISA-preemption windshield, by the 4th Circuit?

Well, the bug-juice seems to be leaking onto New York. It's first Fair Share attempt just got shot down, apparently using the same arguments the Retail Industy Leaders of America used to win in Maryland earlier this year.

Roy Harmon explains what happened over at HealthPlanLaw.com.


The big deal now, according to Paul Secunda at Workplace Prof Blog, is what happens to the Massachusets universal healthcare plan. According to Secunda:

I am now more interested to see if the Massachusetts universal health care plan suffers the same fate. The best thing going for that law is that apparently RILA doesn't believe it causes the same harm to its members as the Maryland and Suffolk County law and has not yet challenged it on ERISA preemtion grounds.

If the only difference between the Fair Share Acts and the Massachusetts UHC plan is that RILA hasn't bit yet, then we're in for a serious fight. RILA's press release doesn't make it sound like they're too afraid to go again. The Fair Share provisions are definitely a big piece of the Massachusetts puzzle. And with other states like California possibly signing onto the Massachusetts mantra, this could get real interesting real fast.

Harmon agrees, focusing on what these decisions mean for any law trying to tax an employer for healthcare coverage under the RILA rulings' interpretation of ERISA preemption:

The idea appears to be that, so long as the tax is not imposed on ERISA plans and does not explicitly suggest a connection with such plans, some form of “pay or play” regime may be imposed on employers as a part of healthcare financing. After Retail Industry Leaders Association v. Fielder, — F.3d —-, 2007 WL 102157, C.A.4 (Md.) January 17, 2007), however, these proposals deserve careful reconsideration.

While [previous decisions] give good reason to believe that lawmakers may impose surcharges on patients or providers, the Fourth Circuit opinion in the RILA decision ... poses a substantial risk to any notion that States may look to employers to supply healthcare financing for State healthcare programs. To the extent [the Court] abandons “literal textualism” and looks to the Congressional purpose of ERISA’s enactment, little can be gleaned that would suggest that ERISA will peacefully co-exist with a multiplicity of State-based employer tax regimes dedicated to the funding of multiple State healthcare programs.
- Another Fair Share Law Bites ERISA Preemption Dust
- NY Opinion - via RILA website

More After the Jump...