Showing posts with label ERISA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ERISA. Show all posts

Monday, May 5

ERISA Makes an Interesting Appearance at the 7th Circuit

The Seventh Circuit's recent decision in Williams v. Interpublic Severance Pay Plan, No. 07-3146 (dec. April 29.2008) seems straightforward enough. It's an ERISA case. It's not very sexy.

But buried in there, underneath the actual legal analysis, are a couple of things worth mentioning.

1. Easterbrook Schools the Academics?
Judge Easterbrook focuses the first part of his holding on the use of trust law in analyzing ERISA cases. This seems appropriate, as the Supreme Court instructed as much in Firestone v. Bruch. But critics of the federal courts' consistent deference to plan administrators' decisions have been chastising the courts for years, saying they ignore trust law in favor of a rough amalgam of contract, administrative and labor law. And no one epitomizes the anti-deference movement like Yale professor John Langbein, who has written extensively on why he thinks the standard of review under ERISA is out of whack.

So it's no suprise when Judge Easterbrook supports deference to the plan's administrator, or when he uses contract law to do it. But when he supports his holding with "See generally John H. Langbein, The Contractarian Basis of the Law of Trusts, 105 Yale L. J. 625 (1995)," call me crazy but that's more than just a holding. That's a shot across the bow.

2. ERISA: the Cartoon
"Second, one must not anthropomorphize 'the administrator.'"

Oh, how many geeky benefits conversations this unfortunate statement could start. What Disney animal would best represent "the administrator?" Would "the administrator" have a high-pitched squeak or a low, dopey voice? How many episodes would it take before "the administrator" would have an anthropomorphically similar character of the opposite gender?

Seriously, though, Easterbrook's point is that administrator's are "commonly large organizations" and don't have any real "interest" in the day-to-day operation of the plan. I know, I know. ZZzzz.

But then, there it was. It might as well have been written in red.

There would be a real conflict of interest if a given administrator put in place a method of linking decisionmakers' income to the substance of their decisions. A quota system...or some other means of tying the wages or promotion of staff to its disposition of claims could call for non-deferential judicial review.

Really? Somebody must have seen "Sicko".

3. Please Deliver 9 Copies to: One First Street, Washington D.C.
Easterbrook ends his interest/deference analysis by noting that (what a coincidence!)the whole thing was presently before the Supremes in MetLife v. Glenn, which was argued (again!) six days before Williams was released. Make of that what you will.

More After the Jump...

Tuesday, March 25

SCOTUS: AARP v. EEOC's ADEA DQ'd


Clearly a statement about the overuse of acronyms, the Supreme Court has denied certiorari in a case between the American Association of Retired Persons and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.

The AARP petitioned after the 3th Circuit upheld a Commission rule that employers can offer reduced healthcare to older workers and retirees once they are Medicare-eligible, without violating the ADEA. The Supremes denied the petition Monday.

For it's part, the AARP was none too pleased. AARP Legislative Policy Director David Certner, via On the Hill:

Beyond blatant age discrimination, the new policy is an ineffective Band-aid for the bigger issue facing American employers and workers: the skyrocketing cost of health care," Certner says. "By allowing employers to reduce or even eliminate health benefits for retirees when they reach age 65, this rule essentially shifts the costs of all retiree health care on to the backs of older retirees.

"Blatant age discrimination" against retirees? You know who else has trouble finding affordable healthcare? Everyone who is still working. You knew when the boomers got in there they'd start fighting each other. Here's my legal analysis: not letting employers adjust healthcare rates for the Medicare-eligible makes as much sense as me suing Hooters for discrimination when it rejected my application as a waitress. I mean if. If it rejected my hypothetical application.

Whatever, you get it. Just because something's not equal doesn't mean it's not fair. Incidentally, the rule was promulgated at the insistance of labor groups and other associations, who feared that employers would reduce retiree health benefits across the board if they couldn't take Medicare eligibility into account.

Still, it's a funny, fickle Court they're running out east. Six months ago, it seemed you couldn't get into the place if you were under 55.

More After the Jump...

Monday, March 24

Let's play catchup...

In case you (we) missed it...

The jobs outlook keeps getting worse, the NLRB only has 2 members, TV is slowly coming back (with the right contract), it's not a great time to be looking for a legal legal job (which is super), and the Supreme Court* decided that 401(k) participants were actually entitled to their money, it doesn't take much to satisfy the EEOC, and Judge Alex didn't actually win.

There, now we're all on the same page. Keep up from now on, huh?

*(For a full[?] list of recent and pending SCOTUS employment law cases, see Ross' Employment Law Blog here).

More After the Jump...

Wednesday, February 20

BREAKING: LaRue Bats 1000 (Or 9, As the Case May Be)

In a much-awaited decision just released, all 9 Supreme Court Justices have agreed that plan beneficiaries (regular joes like you and me) are able to file suit under ERISA to recover money we would have had if the administrators had followed our instructions.

Prior to the LaRue holding, most courts agreed that ERISA limited suits to recover plan losses had to be brought by the plan, for the plan as a whole. LaRue opens the door for regular people to sue for losses to their individual account, reasoning that their account balance is part of the plan balance.

The decision did a fine job of weaving around the most dicey parts of the case beneath - whether "make whole" remedies (i.e. money) are "equitible" enough to be recoverable under ERISA.

More to come.

On the web:
ScotusWiki on LaRue
Workplace Prof Blog Analysis

More After the Jump...

Friday, December 28

San Francisco "Pay or Play" DOA - ERISA Chews Up Another Pay or Play Law

Those of you who have been with us since the beginning (or have done some serious digging) know that one of our first posts at CE was on the unfortunate demise of the Suffolk County Fair Share Act, back in July. We said then that the Retail Industry Leaders of America was on a rampage trying to stop state "pay or play" healthcare laws by convincing federal judges they were per se preempted by ERISA - before Suffolk was a Maryland pay or play law that RILA put the brakes on.

How apropos, then, as we reflect on the year, that another business association has given us opportunity to revisit our earliest days. The Golden Gate Restaurant Association just got summary judgment in a lawsuit against the city of San Francisco in which it argued (what else) that the city's pay or play law, which was to go into effect next week, was preempted by ERISA.

From the Sacramento Business Journal:

Under the San Francisco plan, employers with 20 to 99 employees would have to spend $1.17 an hour per employee on health benefits or pay that amount to the city. Businesses with 100 employees or more would have to spend $1.76 an hour for each employee.

Judge Wright ruled that the mandate interferes with ERISA provisions that specifies employer autonomy over whether and how to provide employee coverage. The decision stems from a lawsuit filed by the Golden State Restaurant Association, which argued the mandatory contributions place a costly burden on business owners.


Man, when ERISA makes the MSM, you know something's going on. Though city attorney Michael Herrera is taking the appeal to the 9th Circuit, it's clear that the state is fighting this battle, since the SF plan is pretty much a petri dish for the statewide plan sitting the Cali Legislature.

As far as Herrera's chances go, his argument is not totally off base. From the city's press release:

“Although state and local laws that dictate employer choices about ERISA plans are preempted, legal requirements that employers may readily satisfy without altering or adopting ERISA plans are not because they do not interfere with uniform benefit plan administration,” Herrera argued. “San Francisco’s Ordinance clearly falls in this latter category, because it allows employers to comply with the health care spending requirement without adopting an ERISA plan or altering an existing ERISA plan. If an employer wishes to avoid the burdens of setting up a plan, or wishes to maintain plan uniformity across jurisdictions, it can simply make payments to the City, and those payments will make their employees eligible for substantial health benefits—benefits that would cost a great deal more in the private market.”


Going against Herrera, of course, is the fact that this argument has completely failed twice before. In his favor is 1.) logic (to a certain extent) and 2.) the fact that the 9th Circuit is crazy, and they seem to like poking the Supreme Court in the face with cases like this.

In the meantime, though, that ERISA keeps getting fatter and fatter on preempted laws. At the risk of biased commentary, may I suggest she at least start chewing up and spitting out, rather than swallowing them whole?

More After the Jump...

Monday, November 26

Eye Witness Report on LaRue Oral Arguments

Just got this email from Marc DeBofsky (ERISA case law wizard and CE's Benefits Litigation professor) and thought I'd pass it along:

From a friend of mine –
Just got back from the oral argument in LaRue [v. DeWolff, Boberg & Associates]
Court asked lots of questions whether the claim should be brought under A(1)(b) versus (a).

Section 502(a)3 was barely discussed and I would doubt that the court will reach that issue at all.

Prediction -- a win under [502](a)2. Votes - 5-4 or 6-3. Kennedy asked no questions.


Anybody else see the show? Any predictions, eye-witness or otherwise, feel free to leave in the comments.

For all the discrimination lawyers out there, LaRue is the ERISA case asking whether individual plaintiffs should be allowed to recover money they would have gained if the 401(k) plan administrators had followed their investment instructions properly. LaRue lost pretty big when his retirement wasn't invested according to his specs.

If you're thinking anything like "well, of course they can, why would congress pass a law to protect people where plaintiffs can't recover under common law theories..." let me just stop you right there. You are entering a world of pain. Just stop. Don't look up the annotated statute or try and find a treatise or anything. Ignorance is bliss, I promise you.

More After the Jump...

Tuesday, October 23

Big Law speaks...IRS listens



That collective sigh of relief you heard yesterday came from the community of Executive Compensation practitioners in response to the IRS extension of the 409A compliance deadline for nonqualified deferred compensation plans to December 31, 2008.

They have the Major Firms - and their clout with the IRS - to thank.

Buried deep in the 600 pages comprising the American Jobs Creation Act of 2004 (many like to say that the Act did, in fact, create jobs...for lawyers, HA!), are found 6 pages constituting 409A of the Internal Revenue Code. This section of the Code was passed to regulate the elections, distributions, and notice requirements of the nonqualified deferred compensation plans loved so much by executives. Congress passed this portion of the Act because it did not like the fact that these execs retained so much control with respect to this supposedly "deferred" compensation.

Bringing affected plans into compliance has proved to be no small task, however, because of a lack of understanding and the sheer number of affected plans. And it didn't help that the Final Regulations under 409A were just passed in April of this year. Those regulations required compliance by December 31, 2007. However, practitioners remained hopeful (and confident) that this deadline would be extended as it seemed unrealistic. Then, on September 10th, the IRS teased practitioners with Notice 2007-78, which allowed for a documentary compliance extension to December 31, 2008. Unfortunately, what really mattered, operational compliance, was not extended.

Finally, a letter was sent to the IRS signed by most major law firms asking for a realistic extension to the end of next year. The IRS listened. On Monday, Notice 2007-86 was published and, among other things, it finally extended the deadline for documentary and operational compliance until the end of next year. Until the deadline comes, plans may rely on "good-faith" compliance with the regulations.

More After the Jump...

Tuesday, October 9

Supremes October Term Blatantly Discriminates Against the Young

The 2007-2008 Term is officially in full swing, so we thought we'd better do our blogitory duty and sum up the Supreme Court's October Docket for you.

We were a little worried about this term. There's been all this talk about the Roberts Court being more interested in business cases, but before last Tuesday the Court had only granted cert to two employment cases, which is pretty low. On 9/25, however, the Supremes tripled their employment-law workload, bringing the total up to seven. That may still seem low, but it's actually a lot compared to past sessions.

We've pored over all the records [read: scanned BNA summaries* while drinking] to bring you as in-depth an analysis as possible, and one thing is very obvious about the new Supreme Court: they are really, really worried about growing old. (Maybe send a gift with that Petitioner's brief?)

An explanation and the case summaries is after the jump.
[*BNA Labor Report - subscription req'd.]


With three employment cases having something to do with the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, and an ERISA case about who can sue for botched 401(k) investments, the Silver Set is definitely taking center stage (for employment cases, which means "far-left stage past the bathrooms" to everybody else).

There's Kentucky Retirement Sys. v. EEOC, a 6th Circuit case that mashes the ADEA, pension benefits and state public employment into one giant mess. This one could be big - the question presented:

Whether any use of age as a factor in a retirement plan is “arbitrary” and thus renders the plan facially discriminatory in violation of the Age Discrimination in Employment Act?


Federal Express v. Holowecki involves whether an "intake questionnaire" and affidavit submitted to the EEOC can be considered a discrimination charge under the ADEA even when the aged discriminitee didn't mean it to. Administrative procedure is obviously the coolest area of the law, so we're sure this will get tons of press.

Gomez-Perez v. Potter asks whether the ADEA prohibits federal employers from retaliating against employees who complain of age discrimination. What? This is a question? Apparently - the 4th Circuit held the ADEA doesn't protect federal employees like it does private ones. Plus, it's not like the government feels the need to live up to its rules for the private sector in other areas... God, it never stops sucking to work for the government, does it?

The term's token ERISA case is a potential barn burner - LaRue v. DeWolff, Boberg & Associates will settle the question of whether the totalitarian regime that is ERISA allows an employee to sue for losses based on his employer's failure to carry out his 401(k) investment instructions. The case got interesting when LaRue moved to dismiss after the Court granted cert, noting that the plaintiff took all the funds out of his 401(k) while the case was pending at the circuit court. The amici came out of the woodwork, and the Court recently denied the motion. For real, keep an eye on this one.

There are two other cases - Sprint/United Management v. Mendelsohn and CBOCS West v. Humphries - that raise game-changing issues in evidence and retaliation, and a state/federal jurisdiction case that is hiding an eminent judicial figure. Since none of them have anything to do with old folks, and this post is getting so dang long, we'll save these three cases for their own post later today.

Finally, the Court denied cert. in Jennings v. Dorrance, the discrimination case against the UNC soccer coach filed by former players. That sends it back to the District Court for trial. It's title IX, which is outside our purview (or interest, honestly) but we knew we'd get emails if we didn't put it in here.

More After the Jump...

Monday, October 8

Fee Disclosure Legislation = Increased Fees

[ed. note: Chad DeGroot is our employee benefits editor. Please be nice to him, because none of the rest of us understand or want to write about this crap.]


On October 4th, Representative George Miller (D-California) introduced a bill in the House seeking to increase transparency with respect to participant-directed defined contribution plan fees charged to participants. The bill essentially requires plans to disclose to each participant every fee charged to their accounts. Failure to properly inform participants would result in a $100 fee per participant, per day of noncompliance for the plan. Not only will this effort not result in a reduction or limitation on the fees participants incur, but it may result in an increase in those fees that were previously seen as unreasonable, or force those plans with relatively high fees to maintain that level.

Because of the increased administrative costs associated with an increase in disclosure, plans will be able to justify current or increased fees. One such administrative cost is going to be borne by HR departments trying to justify the fees to aggravated, uninformed participant-investors.

You think fee litigation has been on the rise as of late? Watch out.

If participants are going to see a reconciliation of the fees charged their accounts, and can understand such disclosure, there is inevitably going to be an increase in the already-saturated field of fee litigation. Much of this new litigation is going to be frivolous, and accomplish nothing but the clogging of overburdened courts and, of course, greater fees. The increase in potential liability and litigation is just going to act as another point on which a plan can justify not only leaving fees at their current levels, but may, in fact, require an increase.

Furthermore, not only will this legislation have no affect on the current fees, unless it provides grounds for an increase, but that which must be included in the disclosure is going to be complicated and convoluted to a point where the average participant will not even read it, or if they do decide to attempt the impossible, not understand it. A similar loophole has been exploited by companies in issuing proxy statements.

Many fees may currently be at inappropriate levels, but increasing the required amount of disclosure to participants is not the answer.

More After the Jump...

Wednesday, September 26

GM - UAW Reach Tentative Deal

We're gathering information right now - but here's what we know:
1. Most importantly for both sides, the auto workers are going back to making cars this morning (thanking God, probably, that they aren't going to be living on 200 bones a week for the next 6 months.)
2. GM has an official statement that the agreement is finalized, and...wait for it... it looks like there's a VEBA! We knew it! Not on the table our ass.

No more healthcare costs for GM (minus that hefty up-front contribution). Interesting. Does this mark a Womakian shift in Detroit? Everyone seems to think the other Big 2 are going to jump in ASAP. Plus, what does assuming 50 billion in healthcare responsibilities mean for the Union? Does this create solidarity or itnernal strife?

We'll keep updating this post throughout the day, as we learn more. In the meantime, discuss in the comments.

UPDATE [10:32 a.m.]: We got emailed that some people wanted an explanation of a VEBA. We scoured the web for one that wasn't written for IRS auditors (i.e.: BORING), and found this fascinatingly well-composed description on the Hopkins k-12 School District Website. We did the math, and CE started learning about VEBAS in 20th Grade. Apparently that puts us at, like, 7th-grade in Minnesota. Kudos to you, libertarians!

UPDATE [9:15 p.m]: Details are trickling out finally - looks like not only did GM catch up to the Minnesota primary education system, they're also getting the 2-tier salary structure they asked for - down to the dollar. From now on, temp and non-manufacturing workers will start at $18/hour, down $10 from the previous contract.

A lot of people seem to think the UAW is calling this a "victory" way too soon, citing a bunch of unanswered questions (like where the 38 bil will come from to fund the VEBA), and that the union is using the short strike to make this a win, when they did all the conceding. If the NY Times is correct, CE agrees:

In return [for taking over 50 billion in healthcare costs] the union won
guarantees that medical benefits for hourly workers and retirees and their
families will remain in place for the next two years. G.M. will also invest
money in its American plants, and will maintain its current union work force of
73,000.

Won? The union "won" that? So the UAW takes over the next 80 years' worth of healthcare costs in return for a promise by GM to keep making cars. If we didn't know it was the UAW, we'd be worried this was adhesion. No such luck - the CE prognosis: the union caved. Hard. Discuss in the comments.

More After the Jump...

Monday, September 24

Huh? Wha?

Seriously, you turn your back for two months...

We know we promised you a full report on the UAW negotiations on the 24th...of July. In our defense, CE had to work out a few administrative details (see here) that took a little longer than expected. All of the sudden it was the 62nd day of the UAW negotiations, and we were sitting around talking about the Second Amendment or some other arcane, unused law like nothing was going on. Honestly, it's not like they're actually negotiating at the moment, so maybe we just saw this coming and didn't want to waste space on the boring parts. All the same, we're a little embarrassed.

Not as embarrassed as, say, Rick Wagoner's gonna be if this strike thing keeps up. Honestly, did anybody realize the UAW still knew how to strike? Of course, each side is blaming the other for the stoppage, but that's not the interesting part of this story.

According to the New York Times, GM is in a much better position to handle a strike now than it has been in the past, but that's really bad news for the company. Confused? We were. For the Times' analysis, and some more stellar CE commentary, keep reading.

First, how great is Rick Wagoner's name? That guy was born to run a car company.

Anyway, according to production guru James P. Womack, this strike is some kind of watershed moment, marking a change for better or worse in Detroit. He says that though GM has backed away from "defining moments" in the past, someone this time finally said enough's enough. Ok, first: backing away from "defining moments" just shows that GM is still the leader of the American Auto Industry. Plus, as the Times article points out, the car company hasn't done anything yet, and it has a, um, "spotty" track record of standing up to strikes. From the article:

In the past, its response, by and large, was to cave in to U.A.W. demands. That happened during the last big walkout, at two parts plants in Flint, Mich., in 1998. That seven-week standoff occurred when Rick Wagoner, the current chief executive of G.M., was president of its North American operations.

(What does this guy have a 10-year itch or something?)
G.M. never recovered the 31 percent market share it held before the strike, and was forced to offer rebate deals to get customers back into showrooms.

“G.M. has made deal after deal that didn’t deal with fundamental problems,” Mr. Womack said. “This time they have to hold the line on a contract.”

"Hold the line"? Yeah, we may not hold our breath. G.M. has about 2 months of reserves to hit the market - not exactly going to get the dealership guys their Christmas hams. Oh, also: the Times article fails to mention that Womack is the chairman (and founder, apparently) of the Lean Institute, which advocates Toyota Production System application to American industries. While there's nothing wrong with that, we're thinking he may have a little bias in defining those "defining moments".

Regardless, it's the other issue here that has the CE staff buzzing like a Halo 3 Mountain Dew Big Gulp: The link between GM's financial difficulties and its negotiating ability. Again, from the Times piece:

G.M. is better positioned to handle a strike now than in earlier contract talks, though not for reasons that have to do with strength. With its operations shrinking in the United States, the majority of its sales and profits are now coming from abroad.

It is selling more vehicles built in Canada, Mexico, and Europe, the source of new models for its Saturn division. And it is rapidly expanding production overseas, especially in China, which is fast becoming one of the world’s major car markets.

The company’s problems at home, which resulted in losses of more than $12 billion in the last two years, have forced it to close all or parts of a dozen factories, cut tens of thousands of jobs and offer deals to workers to quit or retire. A smaller G.M. means there are far fewer workers involved in this strike, so a halt in production inflicts less pain on the company.

The U.A.W. membership at G.M. has shrunk by more than 80 percent since the 1970 strike, when 400,000 workers were off the job for 67 days.


So, GM falls flat on its face financially, which ends up benefitting its bargaining ability and the bouyancy of its bottom line.* When you view this in the light of GM's major goal in this negotiation, the VEBA it hopes will rescue it from the pensions** of the UAW workers, a cycle emerges that is worth some discussion. Since we make it a point not to take sides, the rest of this topic belongs to you - in the comments.

Talks Continue in G.M. Strike
*Intentional alliteration

One last thing - This VEBA has not gotten much attention (alas, ERISA issues never do), so we're promising you a whole post on G.M.'s VEBA proposal and its potential effect on the situation in Detroit...once we track down our Benefits guy. They're so antisocial in the ERISA department...

**UPDATE: Did we say "pensions"? We meant "health and welfare benefits". Thanks to the tipsters for pointing out our mistake - and we reserve the analysis of the value of our education for another discussion.

More After the Jump...

Thursday, July 19

Wal Mart 2, States 0: Suffolk County, NY Fair Share Act Shot Down.

How will all the destitute residents of East Hampton afford their hospital stays?!

Ok, that's a cheap shot, we know. There's plenty of places in Suffolk besides the Hamptons. Still, seems an odd place for championing healthcare reform to us, but what do we know?

Anyway, remember the Maryland Fair Share Act? Sure you do. It was the "pay or play" healthcare law that would've required Wal Mart and other enormous retailers (so, just Wal Mart) to pay a specified amount of their employee's health benefits or pay into a State-run subsidy program. Remember how it was crushed, like a bug on the ERISA-preemption windshield, by the 4th Circuit?

Well, the bug-juice seems to be leaking onto New York. It's first Fair Share attempt just got shot down, apparently using the same arguments the Retail Industy Leaders of America used to win in Maryland earlier this year.

Roy Harmon explains what happened over at HealthPlanLaw.com.


The big deal now, according to Paul Secunda at Workplace Prof Blog, is what happens to the Massachusets universal healthcare plan. According to Secunda:

I am now more interested to see if the Massachusetts universal health care plan suffers the same fate. The best thing going for that law is that apparently RILA doesn't believe it causes the same harm to its members as the Maryland and Suffolk County law and has not yet challenged it on ERISA preemtion grounds.

If the only difference between the Fair Share Acts and the Massachusetts UHC plan is that RILA hasn't bit yet, then we're in for a serious fight. RILA's press release doesn't make it sound like they're too afraid to go again. The Fair Share provisions are definitely a big piece of the Massachusetts puzzle. And with other states like California possibly signing onto the Massachusetts mantra, this could get real interesting real fast.

Harmon agrees, focusing on what these decisions mean for any law trying to tax an employer for healthcare coverage under the RILA rulings' interpretation of ERISA preemption:

The idea appears to be that, so long as the tax is not imposed on ERISA plans and does not explicitly suggest a connection with such plans, some form of “pay or play” regime may be imposed on employers as a part of healthcare financing. After Retail Industry Leaders Association v. Fielder, — F.3d —-, 2007 WL 102157, C.A.4 (Md.) January 17, 2007), however, these proposals deserve careful reconsideration.

While [previous decisions] give good reason to believe that lawmakers may impose surcharges on patients or providers, the Fourth Circuit opinion in the RILA decision ... poses a substantial risk to any notion that States may look to employers to supply healthcare financing for State healthcare programs. To the extent [the Court] abandons “literal textualism” and looks to the Congressional purpose of ERISA’s enactment, little can be gleaned that would suggest that ERISA will peacefully co-exist with a multiplicity of State-based employer tax regimes dedicated to the funding of multiple State healthcare programs.
- Another Fair Share Law Bites ERISA Preemption Dust
- NY Opinion - via RILA website

More After the Jump...